| by JustAThought on February 28, 2010, 12:44 pm in General
|
6 comments |
I recently ran across an article when I was wasting away some downtime at work. Reading it, I was struck by a complex mix of emotions. Anger, rage, sadness, disappointment. Most of all, I was struck with the feeling that the issues I saw in this story (http://nymag.com/news/media/63660/) affect so many black relationships - but they never get discussed in any meaningful way. These issues are:
1. Domestic Violence:
Domestic violence is a serious problem in the black community. Black women are disproportionally represented as victims of domestic violence - even more so as victims of domestic violence homicides. Culturally speaking, black women are not viewed sympathetically as victims of domestic violence, and are accused - even in their own communities - as either deserving/provoking the violence or failing "handle it" because "real black women don't get beat."
Men can also be victims of domestic violence (not indicated in the article). Black men also disproportionately represented as victims of domestic violence, although not to the degree of black women. And if you think that black women are not viewed sympathetically, it's worse for black men. They suffer the double stigma of being a man, and thus should not have been beaten - and being a black man, who is subject to the stereotype of hypermasculinity.
2. Sexual Abuse
Sexual Abuse is another verboten topic in the black community. No one talks about it, yet it is one of the most under-reported crimes that afflict black people. Black women and black children suffer in silence, or get "slut-shamed" if they do come forward. Coupled with the fact that black people are less likely to seek counseling and mental health services, this scourge on our community damages people while leaving them little or no recourse for healing.
3. Lack of Respect
I use this subheading to deal with several things that stood out to me. The lack of respect that led Mr. Carter to abuse his wife, cheat on her, and assume that the woman that helped mold his career was jealous of him. The lack of respect that Mrs. Carter showed when not respecting her husband's wishes to cease all contact with his abusive mother. Whatever the factors that led them to fail to connect with their partners to form a cohesive union, I believe that they were responsible to overcome those factors to truly become one flesh. Lack of respect was the result of them failing to do so.
4. Black Male Privilege
Jewel Woods and R. L’Heureux Lewis (both black men) have published compelling texts and video presentations on black male privilege, so I will point you to their work for an exhaustive definition of this phenomenon. Shortly put, it describes how black men, an oppressed minority group themselves, oppress those they consider weaker, less important, less worthy - black women (and black children). Clearly, Dominic Carter was a selfish person who exerted Black Male privilege in the actions described in the article. Unfortunately, he is not alone is exerting this misguided type of thinking.
5. Mammification of Black Women
Most stereotypes about black women fall into three large umbrellas: Mammy, Jezebel, and Sapphire. Loosely defined, we are selfless mothers, unrepentant whores, or angry bitter women. However, I think the stereotype that gets challenged least is that of Mammy. Even the allegedly positive trope of the "strong black woman" is a dressed up version of the mammy - a woman who has no needs, but is ever-ready to meet the needs of others. She has it together, needs no help, bounces back from anything, and can take on everything. This trope damages black women. It gives them no room to be vulnerable, to put their needs first, to rebel against people and pressures that harm them. It also absolves black men of the responsibility they have to their women and their communities because the Mammy/S.B.W. can handle it all.
6. Disparities in Mental Health Services for Black Americans
The fields of psychiatry and psychology have a blemished track record with the black community. Black people have been disserved by practitioners in this field - labeled as crazy for opposing harsh, abusive, and violent practices/systems (i.e. slavery and Jim Crow), either prevented from receiving treatment or given harsh (and often medically unnecessary) treatments for mild conditions, and stigmatized within the mental health community.
In addition, even with a caring competent mental health professional that's earnest about helping a black client, there often exists a lack of cross-cultural understanding that will assist in them tailoring their knowledge and training to best help their black client. The result is a black client not receiving sufficient help in navigating their mental distresses.
Worse, however, is the fact that blacks are less likely to seek help in the first place. As imperfect as the mental health system is, it can provide treatment and/or relief to those suffering from mental health ailments. Yet, too many black people will not even seek out the treatment because of the negative perception that mental health issues and treatment have in our community. We falsely hold the perception that black people are sooo strong, and that mental health issues are white people's issues, leaving too many of us to suffer in silence without the help we need to get better.
FH family: What do you have to say about these conditions? Have you experienced any of these in your lives? What is your take on the article, and the points I pulled out?
|
On March 3, 2010, 6:25 pm JustAThought says:
@ Mass:
I think it is based on several cultural factors. Black people are conditioned to not talk about "trivial" issues because historically, we had much bigger problems to deal with. Also, the mental health medical establishment - the medical establishment in general - has been less than stellar in its track record with black people. |
|
On March 4, 2010, 11:16 pm Dashon says:
What do you have to say about these conditions? Have you experienced any of these in your lives? What is your take on the article, and the points I pulled out?
@JAT: |
|
On March 4, 2010, 11:16 pm Dashon says:
What do you have to say about these conditions? Have you experienced any of these in your lives? What is your take on the article, and the points I pulled out?
@JAT: |
|
On March 4, 2010, 11:39 pm Dashon says:
Not sure what happened....but let's try this again (smile)
First of all, very well written blog JAT! These are just some of the issues that "we" don't talk about, at least not to the level where we are influencing positive change in these areas. We consider discussion of these very real and very serious issues -- taboo or "too depressing." Well hell, for those that have experienced any of these things directly or seen the impact of them within their own personal universe...I doubt they would agree with that perspective. I can relate most closely to #5: I've experienced being labeled (figuratively) in the all of the ways JAT described in that paragraph. And the fact of the matter is that I can, and have been a little of all of those things at some point in my life. However, I refuse to allow anyone to place me into A box....so while I reject the labels I accept the diversity of who I am as a woman. I can be the domestic (Mammie)--taking care of others; I can be a vamp (Jezebel)- resolute in my desire for sexual gratification; I can be sexy & seductive (Sapphire) and utlitize my femininity to get the attention or things that I crave. What often gets overlooked in these stereotypes are the other parts of who I am. I'm a reformed hood-rat whose street sense is just as lethal as my business savvy. I am a communicator who is able to express myself both verbally and in print. I am an advocate for the homeless. I am a mentor to several young women that are seeking their way in the world. I am a dancer...I can shake it down the soul train line with the best of them. I am...well, I think yall get my point. While there is so much more to us (women); as JAT points out...we are often placed into one of a few boxes....unfortunately (for them), we have angles which make keeping us in those boxes...impossible. |
|
On March 17, 2010, 7:36 am loveless says:
You discussed so many different topics, So I will start with domestic violence. I dont know the ratio of black women -vs- another race but I would say women as a whole are being abused at an unfortunate unproportiional rate. Many times Black women are seen as the perpetrators and white women are seen as victims. Its a double-edge sword for men that are abused. Men are looked at like super heroes, They are suppose to be strong and be able to handle conflict at all cost. This make it hard for some families when the woman is the abuser. Many times the police just shrug woman violence towards man abuse as joke. The children view him as less than and children grow up with distorted values of a real family life.
Black families are taught from a young age that what goes on in the home, stays in the home. This statement alone makes it hard for women to speak out against her abuser, many times the cycle is so vicious that the abuse is never mentioned until the abuser start hitting on the children. This brings me to the next point. If the abuser is the father and he is sexually molesting the children and physically abusing the mother then everyone in the house view this is their only source of survival. No one speaks of the abuse and no one will die. The fear is so deep that this cycle actually goes on for generations. The fear of discussing anything with anyone is so deep rooted that it just may take a few more generations b 4 anyone will come fourth. Just when you think domestic violence on women and children could not get any worse just add in a dose of mental illness to the household. By now everyone has seen the movie Precious. Well that was a fictional story but for many of black americans. The story is real. Many mothers and grandmothers willingly and knowingly allow their husbands, boyfriends or whatever to sexually abuse their children so they can keep him. Thats not only pathetic but its so sad. |

I agree that black people are reluctant to seek treatment when dealing with a lot of these issues you mentioned above. Too many black people suppress certain feelings and issues internally that they become mentally handicapped.
In your opinion why are blacks more reluctant than other groups when there's a need to seek help? Are we too private or we just don't trust indivdiuals enough who may attempt to provide us with possible solutions. Is it a lack of trust within the system as a whole?